Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth: The Best Milkshakes Cincinnati Has to Offer

Laura Williams

Cincinnati is a city that is known for its rich culinary heritage. From its famous chili to its delicious ice cream, the city has a lot to offer when it comes to food. One of the most popular treats in Cincinnati is the milkshake. Whether you are looking for a classic vanilla shake or something more adventurous, Cincinnati has some of the best milkshakes around.


Cincinnati is known for its German heritage, which has influenced many of the city’s culinary traditions. Two other cuisines that share this heritage are Austrian and Swiss cuisine. While all three cuisines share similarities, they also have distinct differences. Austrian cuisine is known for its hearty meat dishes and pastries, while Swiss cuisine is famous for its cheese and chocolate. Milkshakes are a typical part of American Cuisine.


In this article, we will be exploring the best milkshakes that Cincinnati has to offer. From classic diners to trendy milkshake bars, we will be taking a look at the top spots to satisfy your sweet tooth. Whether you are a local or just visiting, this guide will help you find the perfect milkshake to quench your thirst and satisfy your cravings. So sit back, relax, and get ready to indulge in some of the best milkshakes Cincinnati has to offer.


Nomad KY

Nomad KY - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Nomad KY – Photo Source

225 Fairfield Ave Bellevue
(859) 360-7134
Nomad KY Menu


Nomad KY is a fantastic restaurant that offers a wide variety of delicious dishes. The Naughty Nati is a must-try appetizer that is perfect for sharing. The BBQ Mac n Cheese is a standout main dish that is both enormous and satisfying. The Western Taco, Brunch Taco with bacon, and Brunch Tots with Goetta and Over Easy Eggs are all excellent choices for brunch. The gravy on the tots is a standout feature that adds a lot of flavor. The boozy milkshakes are a unique and fun addition to the menu. The pretzels are also a standout dish that is definitely worth trying. While the service may not have been the greatest, the staff were still kind and happy to converse. The prices are fair and the portions are generous. Overall, Nomad KY is a great spot that is definitely worth returning to.


Pendleton Parlor: Ice Cream & Cookie Dough

1218 Broadway St Cincinnati
(513) 381-0925
Pendleton Parlor: Ice Cream & Cookie Dough Menu

Pendleton Parlor: Ice Cream & Cookie Dough is a must-visit for any ice cream lover! The concept of serving cookie dough alongside delicious ice cream is simply genius. The peanut butter ice cream and chocolate chip cookie dough combination is a crowd-pleaser and perfect for sharing with family and friends. The staff is friendly and patient, allowing customers to sample before ordering. The atmosphere is eclectic and brings back old memories, making it a fun place to explore. The Affogato and “side by side” options are a must-try, and the prices are reasonable. The vintage and antique decor adds to the charm of the place. The managers are professional and the young staff is enthusiastic and fun-loving. The only downside is the parking, but it’s worth the extra effort to visit this gem of a parlor. Overall, Pendleton Parlor: Ice Cream & Cookie Dough is a fantastic spot for soft serve or espresso-themed desserts and a great place to make memories with family and friends.

See also  Cincinnati's Top 10 Breakfast Spots


Milk Jar Cafe

Milk Jar Cafe - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Milk Jar Cafe – Photo Source

3880 Paxton Ave Ste M Cincinnati
(513) 818-9141
Milk Jar Cafe Menu

Milk Jar Cafe is a must-visit spot for anyone looking for a refreshing and delicious drink. With a vast menu, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. The Thai Iced Tea with boba and the mango fruit tea with boba are just a few of the many options available. The milk cap ceylon milk tea is also a must-try, with its delicious milk cap that adds a unique twist to the classic milk tea.

The staff at Milk Jar Cafe is friendly and takes pride in their work, making sure that customers are satisfied with their orders. The cafe’s decorations are also worth mentioning, with little details that add to the overall ambiance of the place.

While some reviewers mentioned that the prices were a bit high, the quality of the drinks and the use of real fruit make it worth the cost. Additionally, the cafe offers customizable options, allowing customers to mix and match their drinks to their liking.

Overall, Milk Jar Cafe is a great spot for casual dates, family outings, or group hangouts. With plenty of parking and seating options, it’s a great place to sit back, relax, and enjoy a refreshing drink.



Milkman - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Milkman – Photo Source

1106 Race St Cincinnati
(513) 381-0009
Milkman Menu

Milkman is a must-visit restaurant for anyone looking for a delicious meal in a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere. The menu is filled with mouth-watering options, from the fried chicken club sandwich to the milkman burger and chili cheese fries. The shakes are also a must-try, with a variety of flavors to choose from. The decor is charming and reminiscent of a 50s diner, with booths and tables for seating and even outdoor dining. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure that every customer has a great experience. While some reviewers mentioned the cost being a bit high, the quality of the food and the overall experience make it worth it. Even the negative reviews had some positive aspects, such as the cleanliness of the bathrooms and the well-seasoned fries. Overall, Milkman is a fantastic restaurant that I highly recommend to anyone looking for a delicious meal in a fun and welcoming atmosphere.

See also  Discovering Creole Delights: A Culinary Journey Through Cincinnati's Hidden Gems


Tickle Pickle Northside

Tickle Pickle Northside - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Tickle Pickle Northside – Photo Source

4176 Hamilton Ave Cincinnati
(513) 954-4003
Tickle Pickle Northside Menu

Tickle Pickle Northside is a must-visit for anyone looking for a unique and delicious dining experience. The menu is filled with cleverly named dishes that are sure to make you smile. From the Grateful Shred pulled pork sandwich to the Pearl Jam burger, there’s something for everyone. The ingredients are locally sourced, and the Grippos chips are the perfect side dish. The shakes are also a must-try, although they are a little thinner than some may prefer. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with great music and a patio in the back. Even vegetarians will find something to love with the vegan options available. While some may not consider it their favorite burger joint in town, Tickle Pickle Northside is a gem of a neighborhood spot that’s perfect for hanging out with friends and enjoying some delicious food. Don’t miss out on the Hammstein burger, and be sure to come back to try the Linkin Pork!


Aglamesis Bros

3046 Madison Rd Cincinnati
(513) 531-5196
Aglamesis Bros Menu

Aglamesis Bros is a fantastic ice cream and candy shop that offers a wide variety of selections to choose from. The building itself adds to the experience of stepping into an old-time ice cream parlor, and the staff is super friendly and helpful. The parking lot is also a great convenience for customers. One reviewer loved the fact that they make their ice cream behind the first floor and most of the candies upstairs, making it a hidden historical gem of Cincinnati. The staff is proud to work there and is always ready to help. If you’re looking for a throwback ice cream parlor experience, Aglamesis Bros is definitely the place to be. While there may be some negative reviews out there, we believe that the overall experience is worth it. So come on down and enjoy some delicious ice cream and candy at Aglamesis Bros!


Putz’s Creamy Whip

Putz’s Creamy Whip - <a href="">Photo Source Sarah L. on Yelp</a>
Putz’s Creamy Whip – Photo Source Sarah L. on Yelp

2673 Putz Pl Cincinnati
(513) 681-8668
Putz’s Creamy Whip Menu

Putz’s Creamy Whip is a must-visit for anyone looking for a delicious and nostalgic ice cream experience. The family-run business has been around for decades, and it’s clear that they know how to make a great soft serve. The menu is extensive, with options like banana splits, sundaes, parfaits, cones, shakes, and malts. The ice cream is consistently delicious and fairly priced, making it a great value for families or anyone on a budget.

See also  Sipping on Sweetness: Exploring the Best Bubble Tea in Cincinnati

One reviewer mentioned that they had been visiting Putz’s since they were a kid, and it’s clear that the restaurant has a special place in the hearts of many locals. The friendly and patient staff are always happy to make suggestions, even when there’s a constant line of customers. And despite the fact that the restaurant is cash-only, it’s clear that people are willing to make the extra effort to visit.

While some reviewers mentioned that the restaurant can get busy, it’s clear that the wait is worth it. Whether you’re looking for a fun date spot or a place to take the kids, Putz’s Creamy Whip is sure to deliver. So why not pull up, order a chocolate dipped cone or a strawberry sundae, and make some memories that will last a lifetime?



As someone who loves indulging in sweet treats, I have to say that Cincinnati has some of the best milkshakes around. From classic diners to trendy milkshake bars, there is a wide range of options to satisfy your sweet tooth. One spot that stood out to me was Nomad KY. Their menu offers a fantastic selection of dishes, and their boozy milkshakes are a unique and fun addition. Despite some minor issues with service, the staff was still kind and accommodating. The prices were fair, and the portions were generous. I will definitely be returning to Nomad KY for another round of delicious milkshakes.


In conclusion, Cincinnati is a city that knows how to make exceptional milkshakes. With its rich culinary heritage and diverse food scene, the city offers a variety of options to cater to different tastes and preferences. From the delightful combination of ice cream and cookie dough at Pendleton Parlor to the refreshing and customizable drinks at Milk Jar Cafe, there is something for everyone. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, exploring the best milkshakes in Cincinnati is a delightful experience that will leave you craving for more. So, don’t miss the opportunity to indulge in some of the finest milkshakes Cincinnati has to offer and satisfy your cravings in this culinary paradise.

Leave a Comment

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from You can learn more about our editorial policies here.